|On What There Is|
|Source: Quine - From a Logical Point of View|
|Paper - Abstract|
|Paper Statistics||Books / Papers Citing this Paper||Notes Citing this Paper||Colour-Conventions||Disclaimer|
Frazer MacBride’s Notes on W.V.O. Quine "On What There Is" (MPhil Stud Seminar, Birkbeck, 3rd October 2005)
Fundamental Point: "To be assumed as an entity is, purely and simply, to be reckoned as the value of a variable.... We are convicted of a particular ontological presupposition if, and only if, the alleged presuppositum has to be reckoned among the entities over which our variables range in order to render one of our affirmations true" (OWI: 13).
Structure of paper
There's no necessity to admit non-existent objects because
show that being meaningful and naming are different things.
(TD5): The F Gs ↔ (∃xFx & (∀yFy → x=y)) & Gx
There is no need to admit mysterious entities like being red any more than non-existent things like Pegasus because
Clarifying ontological commitment by comparison with philosophy of mathematics:
realism—logicism, conceptualism—intuitionism, nominalism—formalism.
A criterion of ontological commitment does not tell us what there is, but what someone says there is; whether we accept what someone says is guided by the general ideals of theory construction; a choice of ontology is determined by the over-all conceptual scheme that accommodates science in the broadest sense.
Required reading for Birkbeck MPhil Stud Seminar 03/10/2005; Also in:-
Photocopy filed in "Various - Heythrop Essays & Supporting Material (Boxes)". Note - see "Funkhouser (Eric) - Notes on Quine, “On What There Is”".
Footnote 3: TT: Presumably McTaggart.
Footnote 4: TT: Presumably Meinong.
Footnote 5: TD = “(Russell’s) Theory of Descriptions.” For helpful HTML tags for logical connectives, see Wikipedia: List of logic symbols.
Text Colour Conventions (see disclaimer)
|© Theo Todman, June 2007 - Jan 2019.||Please address any comments on this page to firstname.lastname@example.org.||File output: |
Website Maintenance Dashboard
|Return to Top of this Page||Return to Theo Todman's Philosophy Page||Return to Theo Todman's Home Page|