Amazon Book Description
- To those of us who believe in the inspiration and authority of the Bible, it must surely be a concern to know what it says will happen to the millions around us, some of whom we love dearly, who die without repentance or faith. Does Scripture teach that at the last judgment those who remain unrepentant will be consigned to an unending existence of torment without hope? Is that truly what Jesus and his apostles believed and taught?
- This book presents basic evidence that what they really taught was that the final judgmental end for such people will be “destruction,” taking its obvious meaning that they will cease to exist as conscious individuals.
- The arguments are not complex, because most of the New Testament writers make plain statements to this effect.
- The book also looks at those parables and Revelation passages sometimes taken to indicate unending torment. It links with academic works that in increasing numbers are making the same points, but the book is not a contribution to academic scholarship. Rather, it is a careful, readable, and accessible account to challenge pastors, church leaders, and Christians generally to consider what the Bible actually says rather than rely on tradition.
- "Theologians have often noted that contemporary views of hell owe more to works like Dante's Divine Comedy than to the Christian Scriptures. Similarly, those who turn to the Bible for its instruction on hell are typically surprised by how little it actually says. For both reasons, this book by Paul Marston is a useful and welcome primer."
→ Joel B. Green , senior professor of New Testament interpretation, Fuller Theological Seminary
- "In Hellfire and Destruction, Paul Marston offers a helpful primer on the case for conditional immortality or annihilationism, which is accepted by increasing numbers of evangelical Christians - not because of philosophy or sentimentality, but because the Bible teaches it clearly, as Marston demonstrates."
→ Christopher M. Date, editor of Rethinking Hell
- "Paul Marston's book Hellfire and Destruction offers a well-researched analysis on the outcome of the final judgment. It thoroughly debunks the popular teaching of everlasting torment taught in many churches today and instead upholds the biblical view that the 'wages of sin is death' (Rom 6:23). The book is easy to read but thorough and an excellent contribution to the growing list of studies that reject everlasting torment. Highly recommended."
→ Kim Papaioannou, author of The Geography of Hell in the Teaching of Jesus
- "By carefully reviewing the language, imagery, and argument of Scripture, Paul Marston offers a highly focused clarification that hell does not mean everlasting torment but final destruction. In so doing he helps those of us who identify as evangelicals to articulate the gospel as a testimony to the Judge of all the earth who always does what is right."
→ Nigel G. Wright, principal emeritus, Spurgeon's College
- Paul Marston is a Senior Lecturer at the University of Central Lancashire, and also a Lay Minister in the Free Methodist Church, having gone as a lay delegate to a General Conference in 1989 and acted on various committees. His qualifications include an M.A. in holiness theology from the Nazarene College affiliate of Manchester University, at which he later taught on a Christian Ethics course. He has been on the committee of the British Christians in Science, and has spoken at their conferences and joint conferences with the American Scientific Affiliation. He has had a lifelong interest in philosophy, theology, and apologetics.
Negative Amazon Review
- All but one of the reviews on Amazon are positive, and several are critical of the following review (by 'Preacher'). As this is such a contentious issue, it is worth giving this account of (what used to be) the 'orthodox line' on the matter:-
- Yet again, we have another unscriptural publication promoting the heresy of Annihilationism (also called Conditional Immortality). The publication carries lots of emotive language concerning the 'love of God' and the horribleness of suffering in Hell.
- Much of the 'research' is biased and skewed. Verses are wrested from their context. The author's belief in Conditional Immortality has resulted from a misunderstanding of some of the Bible's doctrines, such as the scriptural teaching on the justice of God (not our perception of it), the consequences and effects of our sin nature, and consequences of sin, the scriptural picture of the nature of Hell. This publication fails to fully appreciate that the lake of fire is both a physical and spiritual realm. A spiritual nature cannot be consumed by physical fire (note the example in Exodus 3:1-17, with Moses and the burning bush that was not consumed). It seems that the unsaved are resurrected with a body prepared for eternity, just as the saved are (Revelation 20:13; Acts 24:15). Both types of bodies are prepared for an eternal fate. The author misconstrues the sense of eternal as presented in Matthew 25:46.
- The author falls back on the clichéd divine justice argument. How could a truly just God commit a person to eternal punishment and torment, if they had only sinned for 30, 40, 50 years. The mistaken belief is that a finite time sinning should result in a finite amount of punishment. The author overlooks the fact that our sin bears an eternal consequence because it is committed against an eternal God (see Psalm 51:4). Annihilationists refuse to truly acknowledge that it is not a matter of the length of time we sin, but the sinless and holy character and nature of the God against whom we sin.
- This expensive book truly misses the mark.
- I doubt this reviewer had actually read the book.
Book Comment
- Wipf and Stock (13 Dec. 2023). New paperback.
- Also purchased for £2.49 on Kindle.
Text Colour Conventions (see disclaimer)- Blue: Text by me; © Theo Todman, 2025
- Mauve: Text by correspondent(s) or other author(s); © the author(s)