(Text as at 18/12/2010 19:58:05)
(For earlier versions of this Note, see the table at the end)
The supposed “world’s worst argument” is a You-Tube video The Atheist’s Nightmare (Link). I found it interesting for a number of reasons. It is probably most effectively debunked by Nick Gisburne (Link), though the response might have been a little more succinct.
In brief, the argument is that the banana is evidence for God’s handiwork, given how convenient it is for humans to eat. The response is that, if this argument is valid, then why did God make such a mess of pineapples and coconuts? Secondly, naturally occurring bananas are nowhere near as nice as the cultivated forms; the only reason bananas show particular evidence of being designed for human consumption is that humans have designed them that way by selective breeding (non-natural selection).
The interest lies in people’s reactions to the video. I’d thought it was some form of spoof, but it seems it isn’t, and that Ray Comfort and Kirk Cameron produce a lot of stuff like this. Also, my initial reaction was coloured by the silliness of choosing the banana as an example – it being a rather comical and rather lewd fruit – rather than immediately pouncing on the paralogisms specific to the example, rather than those that can be levelled against any argument from biological design. My wife Julie’s reaction was also not very logical – she felt uncomfortable about the video, but was probably willing to be convinced. Her worries were that there must be something wrong with it, otherwise I wouldn’t have shown it to her.
All this was sparked off by this link (Link).
|15/02/2009 10:32:10||1679||Creationist Bananas|
|Note last updated||Reference for this Topic||Parent Topic|
|18/12/2010 19:58:05||832 (Creationist Bananas)||None|
|Status: Philosophy of Religion (Summary of Progress to Date)||Theo Todman's Blog|
To access information, click on one of the links in the table above.
|© Theo Todman, June 2007 - January 2018.||Please address any comments on this page to firstname.lastname@example.org.||File output: |
Website Maintenance Dashboard
|Return to Top of this Page||Return to Theo Todman's Philosophy Page||Return to Theo Todman's Home Page|