COMMENSAL ISSUE 103


The Newsletter of the Philosophical Discussion Group
Of British Mensa

Number 103 : October 2000
17th September 2000 Theo Todman

EDITORIAL

  1. PDG Gathering 2001
  2. Mensa at Braziers, October 2000
  3. PDGList
  4. Philosophy for All - PFA
  5. Royal Institute of Philosophy
  6. PDG Web Page
  7. Date of Next Issue (Commensal 104)

We now seem to have resumed normal service, and hopefully it will continue uninterrupted from now on ! Indeed, I've decided to get ahead of the game and issue Commensal 103 before the deadline (this is because I'll be out of commission for a couple of weeks from 26th September - I hope this doesn't upset the plans of anyone hoping to make a contribution to Commensal 103 just before the deadline; as you'll see, we're full ! That said, I'm about to start a part time BA in Philosophy at Birkbeck College, London University, in addition to the day job, so life might be a little fraught for the next four years. We'll see how things go.


PDG Gathering 2001

As announced last time, Roger Farnworth & I need to get going organising next year's Gathering (note the change of name - this is deemed less forbidding than the more august term Conference). It will be on the subject of Consciousness and will be held at Braziers Park over the weekend of Friday May 4th - Sunday May 6th 2001, so please reserve these dates in your diaries. Hopefully in December's Commensal I'll be able to announce the draft programme of events - so if you want to speak - and I hope you will - please let me or Roger (on 01208 821 544) know as soon as possible.



MENSA AT BRAZIERS, OCTOBER 2000

I hope all goes well in early October with Jane Benn's Conference on Education. I also hope we'll in due course receive a summary from Jane or some other attendee. I expect still to be recovering from the uncomfortable after-effects of an operation, so won't attend. A slightly amended programme of events follows :-

THE 100th MENSA INFORMAL RESIDENTIAL DISCUSSION CONFERENCE

Braziers Adult College, Braziers Park, Ipsden, Wallingford OX10 6AN

THE AIMS OF EDUCATION

Chairman: Jane Benn

6th - 8th October 2000

Friday

6th October 2000

18:30

Supper

19:30

Introductory Session - including initial thoughts on what we individually believe to be the main aims of education; delegates are invited to bring their own one-sentence definition.

20:30

Alan Edmonds - Notes on attitudes to education in the UK, including some questions about teaching methods and some European comparisons.

22:00

Refreshments

Saturday

7th October 2000

08:30

Breakfast

09:30

Alan Hassell - What the well-educated adult should know?

11:00

Coffee

11:30

Leslie Haddow The various aims of education and the compromises necessary between them.

13:00

Lunch

Afternoon

Free

16:00

Tea

16:30

John Maxwell - Student-centred education.

18:00

Sheila Haddow - Motivating the individual.

18:30

Supper

19:45

Interlude - Delegates are invited to entertain and educate us with a favourite piece of poetry, literature or music (cl0 minutes maximum); musical delegates are invited to make use of the good piano available, or bring their own instrument. And those who believe that a glass or two of wine would add to the enjoyment are invited to bring an appropriate bottle.

22:00

Tea and coffee

Sunday

8th October 2000

08:30

Breakfast

09:30

Jenny Turner - The relative merits of the Internet, CD-Roms, and books in education.

11:00

Coffee

11:30

Pam Ford - Proposals to bring more intellectual content into Mensa activities.

12:00

Final Discussion and Plans for Future Conferences

13:00

Lunch

Conference ends, but delegates wishing to stay on for informal discussions and tea are welcome to do so.

NOTE

There will be ample opportunity for general discussion after each presentation. Speakers have been asked to restrict their contributions to a maximum of 45 minutes, and most have indicated that they will in fact be speaking for a considerably shorter time.




PDGList

This is the internet discussion group of PDG and invited guests. The list seems very active at the moment, with 45 members. If you don't want to be inundated with emails you can sign up as a "daily digest" member or a "web only member"; the latter option allows you to browse past emails on the web without them clogging up your inbox.

To join PDGList you need first of all to log on to http://www.egroups.com and sign up to eGroups. Then you need to apply to join PDGList itself. You can do this by initially doing a search on "pdglist" and then following instructions. Alternatively, and quicker (though you will thereby miss out on all the wonders of eGroups !), you can go directly to http://www.egroups.com/group/pdglist - again, you will need to join eGroups first (it will prompt you) - and then click on the "subscribe" link or button. Either way, I then need to accept your application. Once accepted, whenever anyone posts anything to the list, you will automatically receive an emailed copy of the posting (subject to the alternatives above). To post something yourself, just email to pdglist@egroups.com and everyone on the list will receive a copy.

Why not give it a go ?

Incidentally, for those who've signed up for PDGList, MS Word 97 versions of all the back-issues of Commensal since I've been PDG Secretary are available in the "Files" area at the PDGList website (http://www.egroups.com/group/pdglist).



PHILOSOPHY FOR ALL - PFA

NOTE : PFA has no relationship with PDG or British Mensa. See C100 (or http://www.pfalondon.freeserve.co.uk) for more details on PFA.

Kant's Cave : On every first Wednesday of the month, from 7pm (lecture at 7.30 pm) PHILOSOPHY FOR ALL meets at "Kant's Cave" for a lecture, debate and social evening. Kant's Cave meetings are now held at the cellar bar of The Penderel’s Oak, 283-288 High Holborn, London (3 minutes' walk from Holborn tube station). Door-charge: £1 (free for PFA members)

UPCOMING KANT'S CAVE LECTURES

4 Oct 2000

Dr. Barry C. Smith (Birkbeck College, London) : tba

1 Nov 2000

tba

6 Dec 2000

Dr. Veronique Monoz-Darde (University College, London)

3 Jan 2001

tba

7 Feb 2001

Dr. Eric Frankel and Dr. Stephen Szanto (Whipps Hospital London) : Brainwashed Youth - A Neuroscientific and Philosophical Appraisal

The PFA at the Mary Ward Centre : Philosophy Debates are to be held approx. monthly on Saturdays 14:00 - 17:00; Dates : 14 October, 2 December, 16 December, 17 February, 3 March, 7 April, 19 May, 2 June, 9 June. There are also Public Lectures on some Saturdays 10:00 - 13:00; Dates : 28 October & 7 April. The Mary Ward Centre is at 42 Queen Square, London WC1N 3AQ. There is no fee.

Philosophy of Science Workshops (Filiz Peach) : Conway Hall, 25 Red Lion Square, WC1R; 19:00 - 20:30. Tuesday 10th October, Tuesday 14th November, Tuesday 12th December. Admission free.

Borders Bookshop, Oxford St.; Wednesday 11th October. Ted Honderich debates with another contemporary philosopher (tba) some questions raised by his part-philosophical, part-autobiographical book Philosopher : a kind of life.



ROYAL INSTITUTE OF PHILOSOPHY

Annual Lecture Series, 2000-2001 : Logic, Thought and Language

NOTE : The RIP has no connection to PDG or Mensa, but I can very highly recommend these lectures.

2000

 

13 October

Mark Sainsbury.
What Logic Should We Think With?

20 October

Gregory McCulloch.
Mental Representation

27 October

Julia Tanney.
Self-Knowledge, Normativity, and Construction

3 November

Barry Smith.
Thought and Language

10 November

Alan Millar.
The Normativity of Intention and Meaning

17 November

Gabriel Segal.
tba

24 November

David Wiggins.
tba

1 December

Crispin Wright.
Relativism and Classical Logic

8 December

Jennifer Hornsby.
Communication

2001

 

19 January

Christopher Peacocke.
tba

26 January

M. G. F. Martin.
Language

2 February

A. W. Moore.
What Are These familiar Words Doing Here?

9 February

Scott Surgeon.
The Conditionality of Thought

16 February

Timothy Williamson.
Possible Beings

23 February

S. G. Williams.
Ambiguity

2 March

Bob Hale.
Logical Knowledge

9 March

Charles Travis.
Rethinking Psychologism

16 March

Paul Boghossian.
Rational Belief

All Lectures to be given at 14 Gordon Square, London WC1 on Fridays at 5.45 pm. Admission is free.


PDG Web Page

Further to the announcement last time about my web-site :-

http://www.kenrick-todman.freeserve.co.uk
or preferably
http://website.lineone.net/~theotodman

which has had rather a lot more gubbins crammed onto it over the last month, I've now set up the PDG web page at the similar alternative addresses :-

http://www.kenrick-todman.freeserve.co.uk/pdg.htm
or
http://website.lineone.net/~theotodman/pdg.htm

The site now contains 9 back issues of Commensal, including the 6 most recent ones. The advantage of the HTML versions is that they allow you to hop around between articles (useful for understanding the mixed-bag commentaries on previous issues).

Hopefully, we'll soon get the links from the Mensa web page, which should help advertise the SIG.

This raises the issue of privacy - we've mentioned this idea for some time, and I pointed out the fact that the site is open to anyone who knows the URL. Currently, not many do but eventually it'll become more widely known. I've probably adopted a rather cavalier approach in just bunging the back issues up there, and it may be that some people don't like the idea of people outside the group reading what they've written (no that this can be prevented - anyone in Mensa can ask for a newsletter). However, if you are sensitive about this issue, please let me know. I can either place your articles on the PDGList web-site (where only PDGList members can access them) or I can omit them altogether. I'd prefer this not to be requested frivolously as it involves me in extra work - but either is technically possible without too much bother, so if you are concerned, do let me know. In the future, I will assume that any article submitted for publication in Commensal is OK for placing on the web-site, unless you tell me otherwise.


You will note that I've made an attempt to return to commenting on the articles submitted, or at least on those early on in this edition of Commensal. Those appearing later deserve comment also, but space ran out. I also want to get this issue off for distribution so I can concentrate on my studies. I hope my remarks aren't too rushed and superficial.


Next Issue of Commensal

The next edition of Commensal (C104) will appear in December. The closing date will be 15th November 2000.

Might I just make one point - given my commitment at the moment, I will no longer have time to type hand-written contributions. My preference is for contributions to be emailed or sent on floppy disk. Otherwise neatly typed and printed using a good ribbon so that I can scan them in. I realise that some of you may not have this capability, so could I ask for a volunteer to offer their services as a typist for those who cannot do so themselves ?

Best wishes !


Theo




Current Editorial (top) (Commensal 103)
Next Article in Current Issue (Commensal 103)
Index to Current Issue (Commensal 103)